His teams never won fewer than 50 games in a full season over the course of his entire career. We check every one, whether it seems like we do or not.īut GOAT should be based on more concrete and tangible things, and if we take an objective look at TD, it’s hard to give a good reason as to why he’s not Top 5 minimum. Please report content that breaks the rules. If you have any questions or concerns, don’t hesitate to contact us via modmail. GOAT, all-time, top 10, or player A vs B posts of all kinds will be removed. Player ranking and comparisons are not permitted. The minimum number of characters needed for a post to not be filtered is 350 characters. Post enough content to provide a jumping-off point. Posts essentially equivalent to “Thoughts?” or “Discuss” are low effort and those posts will be removed. A leading question can be effective, but if you wish to discuss a stance, make it clear where you stand so commenters can address that directly. Asking a well-defined question is a good way to start. Present descriptive, clear, and concise titles. For top-level comments, a character minimum of 75 is in place. Most arguments cannot be deconstructed in one sentence. Accept and acknowledge if you cannot maintain your original argument. This includes your youtube video, website, blog, or twitter.Īttack the argument, not the person. Don't downvote just because you disagree. Vote based on whether the post or comment appears to meet the standards for quality you expect from a discussion subreddit. Unless it is undeniable fact, the burden of proof falls upon the person making the claim. Basketball Reference), and your own statistical analyses should be provided when it strengthens your point. Proofs from trusted NBA reporters, databases (e.g. Support claims with substantiated arguments. Low effort content, including jokes, memes, fanbase attacks, or shitposts will be removed as the moderators see fit. This subreddit is for high quality discussion of the NBA, past, present, and near future. Speak with others how you would like to be spoken with. Please do not refer mockingly to /r/nba and its users. Do not name call, condescend, or belittle others. If you want to separate it further and look at how Tim won 50-plus games throughout his 19-year career, then there's a legitimate case for greatest of all time.This subreddit is for serious, high-quality NBA discussion. Their selections hold some real weight.īryant and Duncan are already two of the most successful players in league history, and this statistic should put them in the top five ever conversation. Bryant's three titles with Shaq were the only times he won it all with a top 75 player while Duncan's titles with Robinson (2) and Kawhi Leonard make up his three.Īccording to the NBA, the 75th Anniversary Team was selected by a "blue-ribbon panel of current and former NBA players, coaches, general managers and team and league executives, WNBA legends and sportswriters and broadcasters." It's hard to discredit the opinions of such a group, which is another reason I don't mind them missing Tony and Manu. For example, Robert Horry's number is made up of Hakeem Olajuwon (2), Shaquille O'Neal (3), Kobe Bryant (3), and Tim Duncan (2).Īs you can see, Kobe Bryant and Tim Duncan both did the most with the least when it comes to winning championships. For each championship, I totaled how many teammates they had that year that made the NBA's top 75. I looked at some of the winningest legends in NBA history and went one by one through the rosters of each of their title-winning teams. So the next time you hear someone making the argument that the help around Duncan is why he won his five rings, I'd like for you to show them this. But news flash, winning titles is hard, and that's what it takes to win multiple rings. Was he helped by players that will probably reach basketball immortality soon? Yes. The opinion that Tim Duncan had too much help to be considered an all-time great shall forever be considered null and void. That argument aside, what the top 75 list did clarify for me was something Spurs fans have known all along. When I consider guys like Vince Carter, Dwight Howard, Grant Hill, and Tracy McGrady also didn't make the 75, it's hard to make the case for Tony and Manu when you don't factor in international accomplishments. Notably absent from the panel's selection were Tony Parker and Manu Ginobili, who both won four NBA championships in San Antonio and are expected to make the Basketball Hall of Fame when they're eligible.Īlthough many Spurs fans were upset with the omissions, I wasn't completely surprised and wasn't even offended. Other San Antonio Spurs to make the cut were scoring legend George Gervin and The Admiral, David Robinson. When the NBA released their full list of the top 75 players of all time, Tim Duncan was likely a first-ballot selection by all panelists asked.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |